Division 1. Cedar Stars Academy vs. NY Shamrock SC
The filing of the Appeal by Shamrocks was valid. However, the player (Max Garcia) did have a valid CSL pass based upon what was known at the time. There was additional evidence provided from the NPSL which confirmed that it was appropriate for Cedar Stars to believe that the player was assessed a 6 game suspension specific to the NPSL as opposed to a 6 month suspension across all leagues. The only aspect where we will revert to the Arbiter is a potential penalty related to the player not signing the line-up form and errors in numbering on the line-up form by the Cedar Stars.